The Persecution and Persistence
of Koa Gora
The North Shore of Oʻahu has been home to many notable figures in Hawaiian history, from ruling chiefs to labor activists, big wave surfers to popular entertainers. Less known is a former teacher and WWI veteran who stands out as a rare figure in Hawaiʻi’s early civil rights history willing to challenge the harsh system of morality laws that policed and regulated intimacy and relationships during the Territorial period. His name was Koa Gora.
Life in the Territory of Hawaiʻi
Born in Waialua on April 12, 1891, Jacobson Koa Gora was the son of an immigrant Japanese father and Portuguese mother, reflecting the cultural blending common in the plantation era. He earned a teaching certificate and taught in Waialua before being drafted and serving as a cook in the U.S. Army during World War I. He was honorably discharged in 1919.
Koa Gora’s military service record.
Over the next two decades, Gora repeatedly attracted police attention in ways that suggest involvement in same-sex relationships. In 1933, he reported being robbed by two men after an early-morning encounter, telling police he would drop the matter if his belongings were returned - hinting at a personal dispute rather than a random crime.
Honolulu Advertiser, 12/22/33
In 1934, newspaper reports indicated that Gora was indicted for a charge linked to "moral turpitude," a common euphemism that the press used for same-sex activity. Court records show that he was indicted for “the abominable and detestable crime of sodomy,” and that his defense team requested a medical examination. His attorneys requested a medical examination, and three doctors declared him insane. The criminal charges were dropped, but Gora was committed to the Territorial Hospital for the Insane in Kaneohe. This outcome reflected prevailing beliefs that homosexuality was a mental illness rather than a legitimate identity.
Honolulu Advertiser, 3/20/34
By 1942, Koa Gora had returned to Honolulu, going by the name “Jake.” He made his living by operating an unlicensed rooming house, “Jakeʻs Place,” a common practice to accommodate the influx of American troops during World War II. The business operated in a Portuguese neighborhood on the slopes of Punchbowl, where it soon attracted the attention of authorities; he was fined $100 (approx. $2,000 today) for hosting a so-called "wild party."
Aerial photograph of Punchbowl, circa late 1940s. The red circle indicates the location of Jake’s Place.
Honolulu Star-Bulletin, 9/20/42
A Fight for Justice
The next year, Jake’s Place became the site of the legal case that brought Koa Gora to lasting attention in the annals of Hawaiʻi’s LGBTQ+ legal history when he was arrested for bootlegging and “attempted indecency.” This time, however, he decided to stand against the charges rather than accept them passively. He appealed the district court's decision to the circuit court, where he was retried but again found guilty of “lascivious conduct,” another term used to describe same-sex interactions.
Honolulu Star-Bulletin, 7/17/43
Determined, Koa escalated his appeal to the Supreme Court of Hawaiʻi. His argument centered not on disputing the facts of the case but rather on the legitimacy of the charges themselves. He contended that the accusations lacked sufficient clarity regarding the nature of the claimed offenses, thus violating his Sixth Amendment rights and denying him the opportunity to properly prepare his defense. His lawyer argued that the statutory language surrounding “lascivious conduct” invokes the offense as it was known to the common law, namely a public demonstration toward a person of the opposite sex, but because the court failed to state exactly what it was that he actually did, that they couldn’t punish him for it.
The appellate court disagreed, emphasizing that the Hawaiian law referenced “any man or woman who is guilty of lewd conversation, lascivious conduct, or libidinous solicitations,” without regard to whether such was committed in public or in private, or even saying exactly what the accused had done.
Honolulu Advertiser, 9/17/44
Undeterred, Koa Gora pursued his case to the federal judiciary, bringing it before the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals in 1946. His Hawaiʻi attorneys were Fred Patterson and E.J. Botts, both well-known for their civil rights work including challenging martial law during World War II and defending abortion cases. Their primary argument mirrored that presented in the Hawaiʻi court: the law against "lascivious conduct" was too vague and lacked a clear standard of guilt. They contended that the charges against Gora were inadequately defined, leading to a denial of due process.
In their ruling, the federal judges, for the first time, described what happened on the night of the arrest:
“At about 10:30 a.m., on July 6, 1943, one Arthur Notikai, a shore patrolman with the United States Navy, went to the premises on Kamamalu Street in Honolulu where appellant conducted a rooming house. Notikai, accompanied by a member of the Honolulu Police Department, went there to make an investigation of the place. He entered the premises alone, allegedly looking for a room. Appellant conducted him to a small building on the premises containing a room with shower and toilet. While in this room, appellant unbuttoned Notikai's trousers and laid his hands on his private parts.”
Court of Appeals, Ninth Circuit. Koa Gora v. Territory of Hawaii. 1946
The justices had little doubt that this rather modest indecorum was indeed “lascivious conduct,” which they noted was defined by the Supreme Court as “that form of immorality which has relation to sexual impurity.” They further argued that there was no requirement to be specific because “the indelicacy of the subject forbids it” – a rather remarkable sidestep that emphasizes just how uncomfortable people were with same-sex relations. The reasoning was rooted in “the common sense of the community, as well as the sense of decency, propriety and morality, which most people entertain.” In other words, if the majority thinks something should be illegal, it effectively is.
Despite this setback, Gora was not ready to concede defeat. He took the extraordinary step of appealing to the U.S. Supreme Court. Sadly, his fight was cut short when he passed away on April 26, 1946, at the 148th General Hospital in Schofield, Oʻahu. He left behind three married sisters and four brothers, two of whom served as policemen, alongside a customs official and a professional boxer.
Honolulu Advertiser, 7/5/46
Honoring Koa Gora at Puʻuiki Cemetery
Koa Gora was not a gay rights activist in the contemporary sense. He was simply a man demanding a fair trial who wasn’t afraid to publicly challenge the legal system to get it. Although he was unsuccessful in changing the law or its interpretation—a fight that would not conclude until the revision of the Hawaiʻi penal code in 1973—he did make an important contribution: a clear, on-the-record, challenge to a legal and political system that criminalized and brutally punished same-sex desire and relations. It was a rare public refutation in an otherwise compliant social landscape.
Gora's final resting place is in the Puʻuiki Cemetery, near his childhood home, in Waialua — a quiet marker of a man whose life helped expose the foundations of inequality long before reform became possible. His grave is accessible to visitors and serves as a visible testament to his courageous legacy and the ongoing struggle for justice, equity, and inclusion.
Koa Gora’s gravesite and headstone at Puʻuiki Cemetery in Waialua, Oʻahu.
Story by Dean Hamer and Joe Wilson for Lei Pua ʻAla Queer Histories of Hawaiʻi.
Mahalo nui loa to Rose Woods for information about Puʻuiki Cemetery.
Legal Cases:
Supreme Court of the Territory of Hawaii. Territory of Hawaii v. Koa Gora. 37 Haw. 1, decided Sep. 14, 1944.
Circuit Court of Appeals, Ninth Circuit. Koa Gora v. Territory of Hawaii. 152 F.2d 933, decided Jan. 4, 1946
The banner image is an imagined artistic rendering of Jake’s Place in Honolulu’s Punchbowl neighborhood circa 1940.